Broker or Marketplace? How Business Sale Fees Compare
Selling a business costs money in three ways: a success fee paid at closing, any upfront retainer or listing fee, and the advisers you need regardless, such as attorneys and accountants. Fees differ by channel: traditional brokers, M&A advisors, managed marketplace services and self-serve listings.
Instead of chasing a headline percentage, compare what you keep after every cost. Below is how the models work, the questions to put to each provider, and a worked calculation.
Vendors Covered in this Article
Disclosure: We may earn a commission if you buy through some links on this page. It doesn't change what we recommend.
How do the main sale channels charge?
There's no universal price list, and terms change, so treat this as a map of the models and get current quotes:
- Traditional business brokers: usually a success fee as a percentage of the sale price, sometimes with a minimum fee and an upfront retainer. Many work on smaller local businesses and often ask for an exclusive listing period.
- M&A advisors: for larger deals, they often combine a monthly retainer with a success fee, sometimes on a sliding scale that drops as the price rises. They typically prepare marketing materials and run a buyer process.
- Managed online brokerages: these handle audit, listing and buyer vetting for online businesses and charge a success fee, sometimes tiered by deal size.
- Self-serve marketplaces: you list the business and negotiate yourself. Some charge sellers little or nothing to list, with costs falling on buyers or on optional services, so confirm who pays what.
The traditional Lehman formula is one sliding scale: a fixed percentage on the first million, a smaller percentage on the next, and so on. Ask any advisor whether they use it or something else.
What should you ask before signing an agreement?
Fees are only part of the agreement. Ask about each of these, and get the answers in writing:
- What's the success fee, and on what amount? Total price, cash at closing, or including earnouts and assumed debt?
- Are there retainers or listing fees, and are they credited against the success fee?
- How long is the exclusive period, and what happens if you sell to a buyer you found yourself?
- Is there a tail period after termination during which you still owe a fee?
- What's included: valuation, financial normalization, marketing materials, buyer screening, negotiation support and closing coordination?
- Who pays for escrow and legal work?
- What buyers do you reach, and how do you qualify them?
A low headline fee can hide a long exclusive period or extra charges, and a higher fee can be worth it if the advisor brings buyers you couldn't reach. The executive search fee guide shows a parallel: contingent versus retained pricing.
How do you compare offers on net proceeds?
Build a simple side-by-side. Use your own numbers and a realistic range of prices.
For example, say you expect a $2,000,000 sale and are choosing between two options.
- In this example, Option A charges a flat 10% success fee and nothing upfront, so it costs $200,000.
- In this example, Option B charges a 6% success fee plus a $10,000 retainer that isn't credited, so it costs $130,000.
In this example, Option B looks $70,000 cheaper. Now suppose Option A's wider buyer reach produces an offer of $2,300,000, while Option B's best offer is $2,000,000. In this example, Option A leaves you $2,070,000 after its fee and Option B leaves you $1,870,000. The cheaper fee doesn't always win: the real question is which channel realistically produces the higher price and the better chance of closing.
Set out these lines for each channel:
- Expected sale price, and a range.
- Advisor fees and retainers.
- Legal, accounting and escrow costs.
- Your time and the probability the deal closes.
- Net proceeds after all costs and taxes, which your CPA should model.
Which channel fits which business?
Match the channel to your business type and how much help you want:
- Small local or main-street businesses often use traditional brokers because their buyers are local and want a familiar process.
- Software and internet businesses often sell through online marketplaces or specialized brokers who understand recurring revenue and technical due diligence.
- Larger companies with complex operations usually need an M&A advisor who runs a formal process and can manage buyer confidentiality.
- Founders who want control and can devote the time might list on a self-serve platform and use attorneys for the paperwork.
The comparison of Acquire.com, Flippa and Empire Flippers and its B2B version explain how those platforms differ in the type of seller they serve. Ask each what fees apply to your specific deal, since published terms change.
What else should you plan for before you sell?
Fees are one line of the transaction. Prepare the rest early so the process doesn't drag and cost more.
- Clean up your financials and document add-backs using the 12-month sale preparation checklist.
- Understand what a letter of intent will ask of you, especially exclusivity.
- Get a valuation range from more than one source, and don't rely only on the advisor who benefits from listing you.
- Have a CPA model taxes on different deal structures, since the way price is allocated can change what you keep.
Read any engagement agreement with an attorney. Tail periods, exclusivity and fee definitions are where sellers most often find surprises.
What Good Looks Like
A seller compares channels on net proceeds after every fee, term and cost, with the engagement agreement checked by an attorney before signing.
Building The Capability (5-Stage Skill Ladder)
How to Get Started
Disclosure: We may earn a commission if you buy through some links on this page. It doesn't change what we recommend.
Fits a founder of a software or internet business who wants to compare a marketplace route with a broker.
Fits an online-business owner who wants a brokerage that manages the sale process, and should confirm fees for a specific deal.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the Lehman formula?
It's a traditional sliding-scale commission in which a higher percentage applies to the first slice of the price and lower percentages apply to later slices. Variations exist, and many advisors now use flat or custom fees, so ask what applies to you.
Can I sell a business without a broker?
Yes. Some owners list directly on online platforms or sell to a known buyer, using attorneys and an escrow service for the paperwork. You take on the marketing, buyer screening and negotiation work yourself.
Who pays the broker fee in a business sale?
Usually the seller, out of the proceeds at closing. Some platforms charge buyers fees as well. Confirm in the engagement agreement who pays what, and when.
What is a tail period in a broker agreement?
It's a period after the agreement ends during which the broker still earns a fee if you sell to a buyer they introduced. Ask how long it lasts and how the buyer list is defined.
About the numbers
This guide doesn't quote a sourced benchmark. Figures in it are estimates or general guidance, so check them against your own numbers.
Related Guides
Executive Search Fees: Retained vs Contingent Pricing Explained
How executive search firms price: retained, contingent and hybrid models, what the fee covers, a worked example, and terms to negotiate before you sign.
Acquire.com vs Flippa vs Empire Flippers: Exit Comparison
Compare Acquire.com, Flippa, and Empire Flippers for tech startup acquisitions. Evaluate buyer vetting, deal escrow, valuation multiples, and fees.
Selling a B2B Marketplace: Questions Founders Ask
Common questions from B2B digital marketplace and trading platform founders about comparing Acquire.com and Flippa when preparing to sell.
Preparing a Business for Sale: A 12-Month Plan
A 12-month plan to get a business ready to sell: clean financials, add-backs, customer concentration, founder dependence, legal cleanup and a data room.
Letter of Intent for Buying a Business: Terms, Exclusivity and Escrow
What goes into a letter of intent for buying a business: price, structure, working capital, escrow, exclusivity and which terms bind, from both sides.
Contingent vs Retained Executive Search: Which to Use
How contingent and retained executive search fees actually differ, and which fee structure fits a given senior hire based on urgency and difficulty.