Hiring in Canada From the US: EOR, Subsidiary or Contractor?
A US company can hire in Canada in three ways: through an employer of record (EOR) that employs the person on your behalf, through its own Canadian subsidiary or registration, or by engaging a true independent contractor. An EOR is usually the fastest for a first hire or two.
The choice matters because Canadian employment rules are set mostly by province and differ from US at-will practice. Here's how to pick a route, what to check before the first offer, and which mistakes cost the most.
Vendors Covered in this Article
Disclosure: We may earn a commission if you buy through some links on this page. It doesn't change what we recommend.
Which hiring route fits your situation?
Compare the three options on what you need:
- Employer of record: a provider that's already set up in Canada becomes the legal employer for payroll, tax remittances and benefits, while you direct the daily work. It suits a small number of hires, a test market or a need to start quickly. Confirm the fees, the contract term and what you own if you later move the employee to your own entity.
- Your own Canadian entity or registration: you run payroll, benefits and filings directly. It gives control and can make sense once you have a team, an office or a long-term plan, but it needs accounting, payroll and legal support in Canada.
- Independent contractor: only appropriate when the person is truly independent, as described in the international contractor agreement guide. Treating someone who works like an employee as a contractor creates risk.
The entity vs EOR vs contractor comparison and its decision tree go deeper on the tradeoffs. For the specific providers, see Deel vs Remote.
What does Canadian employment law expect from you?
Employment standards are mostly provincial, so the rules for someone in Ontario, British Columbia or Quebec aren't identical. Before you draft an offer, check these areas with an EOR or Canadian employment lawyer:
- Termination: at-will employment doesn't exist in the same way. Ending employment without cause generally requires notice or pay in place of notice, and courts can award more than the statutory minimum. A written contract with clear, compliant termination terms matters.
- Vacation, holidays and overtime: minimum vacation, statutory holidays and overtime rules vary by province.
- Payroll deductions and contributions: employers withhold income tax and contribute to national programs such as the Canada Pension Plan and Employment Insurance. Some provinces add their own levies.
- Benefits and leave: health coverage practices and required leaves differ from US norms.
- Language: in Quebec, employment documents are subject to French-language rules, so ask counsel before sending an English-only contract.
Don't assume a US offer letter can be relabeled for Canada. It usually can't.
What is the pre-hire checklist?
Work through these steps before you make an offer:
- Decide the role, the province of residence and whether the work is genuinely full-time employment.
- Pick the hiring route and confirm the EOR or your advisors can support that province.
- Get the total cost estimate, including provider fees, employer contributions, benefits and any relocation or equipment.
- Prepare a Canadian-compliant employment agreement with confidentiality and IP assignment language that works in that province.
- Set up payroll and benefits before day one.
- Decide how the person will access your systems and data, and how you'll handle privacy obligations for their personal information.
- Write down the offboarding process, including notice or severance expectations.
For context on the wider cost of a hire, SHRM's 2025 benchmarking reports an average cost-per-hire of $5,475 for nonexecutive hires1. Add the EOR or entity costs on top when you budget.
What are the tax and entity risks of hiring without setting anything up?
Putting a Canadian resident on a US payroll or paying them informally is the mistake to avoid. It can create payroll withholding gaps, and it can raise questions about whether your company is doing business in Canada for tax purposes. The details depend on your business, the role and any tax treaty, so ask a cross-border tax advisor before hiring.
Signs you've outgrown an EOR include hiring several people in the same province, having a manager or sales leader who signs contracts locally, or needing to hold assets or a bank account there. At that point, compare the ongoing EOR fees with the cost of a subsidiary, and involve your CPA.
If you also have a team in Asia, the Philippines checklist shows how the same decision looks in a different legal system. Founders who are not US-based can find setup notes in the US LLC guide for non-US founders.
How to compare EOR providers for a Canadian hire
When you request quotes, use the same questions for each provider so you can compare them fairly:
- Which provinces do you support, and do you employ people directly in each?
- What's the total monthly fee, and what does it exclude?
- What's the minimum contract term and the exit process if you want to transfer the employee to your own entity?
- Who drafts the employment agreement, and can you review it?
- How do you handle IP assignment, confidentiality and benefits?
- What happens if the employee is terminated, and who pays severance?
Ask for the answers in writing and have them checked by Canadian counsel if the role is senior. Prices, coverage and terms change, so confirm them on a call and in the contract instead of relying on anything published.
What Good Looks Like
A US company hiring in Canada picks the right employment route, follows provincial rules, sets up payroll before day one and uses a written agreement suited to the province.
Building The Capability (5-Stage Skill Ladder)
How to Get Started
Disclosure: We may earn a commission if you buy through some links on this page. It doesn't change what we recommend.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can a US company hire in Canada without a Canadian entity?
Yes, commonly through an employer of record, which employs the person on paper and handles payroll and compliance while you manage their work. A true independent contractor is another route, but only if the working relationship supports it.
Does Canada have at-will employment?
Not in the way the US does. Ending employment without cause generally requires notice or pay in place of notice under provincial law, and courts may require more. Use a compliant written agreement and get advice before any termination.
How much does an EOR cost in Canada?
Fees vary by provider and change over time, and they sit on top of salary and mandatory employer costs. Get written quotes from at least two providers and compare the total monthly cost, not just the headline fee.
Should I hire a Canadian as a contractor to keep things simple?
Only if they're genuinely independent, with their own business, other clients and control over how they work. If the role looks like employment, contractor status can backfire, so choose an EOR or your own entity.
Sources
Where we quote a benchmark, we show its source. Other figures in this guide are estimates or general guidance, so check them against your own numbers.
- Average cost-per-hire (SHRM 2025 Benchmarking). SHRM 2025 Benchmarking Reports press release, 2025.
Related Guides
International Contractor Agreement: Clauses a US Company Needs
What to include in an agreement with a contractor outside the US: IP assignment, moral rights, tax forms, independence terms, payment and dispute resolution.
Entity vs EOR vs Contractor: International Hiring Strategy
International hiring structures compared: foreign entity costs, employer of record fees, contractor misclassification, and when to convert.
Entity, EOR or Contractor: A Decision Tree for Global Hiring
A step-by-step decision tree for choosing a foreign entity, an employer of record or a contractor when hiring abroad, with tradeoffs and risks.
Deel vs Remote: Best Employer of Record for Scaling Teams
Comparing Deel and Remote: entity infrastructure, compliance exposure, IP protection, pricing models, and when each is the wrong choice.
Hiring in the Philippines: Contractor or Employer of Record?
Decide between contractor and employer-of-record hiring in the Philippines, and check 13th-month pay, statutory contributions, probation rules and work hours.
A US LLC for a Non-US Founder: Setup, Banking and Tax Steps
How a non-US founder can set up a US LLC: choosing a state, registered agent, EIN without an SSN, US banking and the annual IRS filing many owners miss.