Forming an Audit and Compensation Committee Before You Need One
A board committee that exists only as a line on the org chart doesn't do anything. It needs a written charter, a defined scope of what it can decide versus recommend, and members who actually have the independence to disagree with management.
Most companies stand these up too late, right before a financing or an audit forces the issue, instead of building the habit while the decisions are still small enough to get wrong safely.
Vendors Covered in this Article
Disclosure: We may earn a commission if you buy through some links on this page. It doesn't change what we recommend.
What actually belongs to the audit committee versus the full board
The audit committee's core job is overseeing the relationship with the outside auditor, not doing the accounting itself: selecting and evaluating the auditor, reviewing significant accounting judgments before they're finalized, and owning the whistleblower and internal controls process described elsewhere on this site.
Keep day-to-day accounting decisions with management and the CFO. The committee's value comes from asking hard questions about judgment calls, not from re-performing work the finance team already did.
What actually belongs to the compensation committee
Executive compensation design, equity grant approval above whatever threshold the board sets, and reviewing the company's overall comp philosophy sit here. The committee should set the CEO's compensation directly, with the CEO not present for that discussion, rather than having the CEO effectively propose their own number to a board that just ratifies it.
Non-executive comp policy, like the standard offer bands for engineering hires, can stay with management as long as the committee reviews the framework periodically rather than every individual offer.
The independence rule that trips people up
A director who also holds a consulting agreement, a large customer relationship, or a close personal relationship with the CEO usually isn't independent enough to sit on either committee, even if they're a perfectly good board member overall. This isn't about competence, it's about whether their vote could reasonably be seen as compromised.
Smaller boards sometimes don't have enough independent directors to staff both committees cleanly. If that's the case, name it explicitly in the charter and plan to add independent directors at the next round rather than quietly working around the gap.
Writing a charter that does more than restate the obvious
A charter should specify: who can serve, how often the committee meets, what needs committee approval versus what just needs to be reported to it, and how it escalates a disagreement with management to the full board. A one-paragraph charter that just says the committee "oversees compensation matters" gives no one, including the committee itself, a clear sense of its own authority.
At a minimum, a working charter answers these questions:
- Who can serve on the committee, including the independence standard each member must meet.
- How often the committee meets and how it keeps its own minutes, separate from the full board's.
- Which matters need the committee's approval and which only need to be reported to it.
- How the committee escalates a disagreement with management to the full board.
Sequencing: which committee to form first
Form the compensation committee first if you're actively negotiating executive offers or fundraising, since comp decisions come up constantly and an ungoverned process there creates the most immediate risk. Form the audit committee before your first outside audit or before a Series B, whichever comes first, since due diligence will ask directly whether one exists.
If you already run continuous compliance tooling like Vanta or Drata, use the evidence trail it's building on other controls as a model for what the audit committee should expect to see on financial controls too.
Keeping committee minutes separate from full board minutes
A committee should keep its own minutes, distinct from the full board's, even when the same people are in the room for both. Folding committee business into general board minutes makes it hard to show later that the committee actually reviewed something with the specific scrutiny its charter calls for, rather than the topic just getting a passing mention in a broader meeting.
Report a short summary of committee actions to the full board at the next meeting, in writing, even for routine items. This keeps the rest of the board informed without requiring every director to sit through the committee's own detailed discussion.
Keep committee minutes to a similar standard of detail as full board minutes: what was discussed, what was decided, and who voted which way if it wasn't unanimous. A committee's minutes get the same scrutiny in diligence or litigation as the board's own.
What Good Looks Like
A real committee has a written charter, a defined scope of what needs its approval versus a report, and members who meet the independence bar for that committee's specific role.
Building The Capability (5-Stage Skill Ladder)
How to Get Started
Disclosure: We may earn a commission if you buy through some links on this page. It doesn't change what we recommend.
Extend the compliance evidence Vanta already collects to the financial controls the audit committee is supposed to review, so the committee isn't working from a blank slate.
Use Drata's evidence trail from other controls as the model for what the audit committee should expect documented on financial reporting too.
Frequently Asked Questions
How many directors need to sit on each committee?
There's no fixed number, but most boards use two or three, enough for a real quorum and a real discussion without duplicating the full board. What matters more than headcount is that the members assigned actually meet the independence standard for that committee.
Can the CEO sit on the compensation committee?
Generally no, and definitely not for discussions of their own pay. A CEO effectively setting their own compensation, even informally by being in the room for the vote, undermines the entire point of having a separate committee.
Do we need both committees before our first outside financing round?
Not always at seed, but investors and their counsel often ask about governance structure as the company scales, and having neither committee in place by a Series A or B can raise questions in diligence. Standing them up before it's asked for looks far better than reacting to the question.
What if we don't have enough independent directors yet?
Say so explicitly in the charter rather than pretending the gap doesn't exist, and set a plan to add independent directors at the next round. A board that's honest about a temporary limitation is in a much better position than one that quietly ignores its own independence rules.
About the numbers
This guide doesn't quote a sourced benchmark. Figures in it are estimates or general guidance, so check them against your own numbers.
Related Guides
Does Using an Employer of Record Create Permanent Establishment Risk?
An employer of record doesn't automatically remove permanent establishment risk. Learn what triggers it, how to lower it and when to get tax advice.
The IP Assignment Gaps That Show Up in Diligence, Not Before
The specific gaps in IP assignment paperwork that buyer's counsel finds first: pre-signing contributions, contractor language, and prior employer overlap.
Paying Independent Directors at a Private Company: Cash and Equity
How to structure independent director pay at a private company: cash retainers, equity grants, vesting, indemnification, and the questions to settle first.
How Executive Pay Shifts From Seed to Series B
How cash and equity mix for senior executives typically shifts from seed through Series B, and how to benchmark pay without overpaying for stage.
The Governance Gaps a Pre-IPO Readiness Audit Actually Finds
What a pre-IPO governance audit checks, from SOX 404 controls to board committee independence, and how long the gaps typically take to close.
The 83(b) Election Deadline Founders Actually Miss
Why the 83(b) election window is so short, what happens if you miss it, and how founder salary versus equity typically gets structured around it.