MAE Clauses: When a Buyer Can Actually Walk Away
A material adverse effect clause, often shortened to MAE, gives a buyer an out if something happens to your business between signing and closing that is bad enough to undermine the deal. It sounds like a broad escape hatch, and buyers sometimes try to use it that way, but courts have historically set a very high bar for what actually counts.
Understanding the clause from both sides tells you how much real risk it represents and what is worth negotiating before you sign.
Vendors Covered in this Article
Disclosure: We may earn a commission if you buy through some links on this page. It doesn't change what we recommend.
What a buyer actually has to prove
Courts that have ruled on MAE disputes have generally required a buyer to show a change that is durationally significant, not a short-term dip, and substantial relative to the company's earnings power over a period of years, not a single bad quarter. This is a genuinely high bar, which is part of why buyers rarely succeed in actually walking away from a signed deal by invoking a MAE clause, even when they clearly want to.
The carve-outs that do most of the real work
Most MAE definitions exclude broad categories of change that affect the whole economy or industry, not just your company specifically, such as general economic conditions, changes in law, or industry-wide disruptions, unless your business is disproportionately affected relative to comparable companies. As a seller, push to keep these carve-outs broad, since they are what actually protect you from a buyer trying to use a market downturn as an excuse to renegotiate or walk.
Where sellers should focus their negotiating energy
Rather than fighting over the legal standard itself, which is fairly well established, focus on the carve-out list and on any specifically negotiated exceptions relevant to your business, such as the loss of a single large customer or a known pending issue you have disclosed. A well-drafted disclosure schedule that specifically calls out known risks can prevent a buyer from later claiming those same known issues constitute a surprise MAE.
How this plays out in practice during the interim period
Between signing and closing, keep a written record of anything happening in your business that a buyer might later characterize as adverse, along with your own assessment of whether it is a normal, ordinary-course fluctuation or something genuinely unusual. If a buyer starts signaling reluctance to close, this contemporaneous record is far more useful than trying to reconstruct the story after the fact.
What to actually negotiate before you sign
Push for a MAE definition with broad, specific carve-outs, a disclosure schedule that flags known risks explicitly so they cannot later be called a surprise, and, if your negotiating position supports it, a specific performance provision that limits the buyer's practical ability to simply refuse to close and pay you damages instead. These provisions matter more to your actual risk than debating the legal definition of the term itself.
Ask for these protections before you sign:
- A material adverse effect definition with broad, specific carve-outs for economy-wide and industry-wide changes.
- A disclosure schedule that names known risks explicitly so they cannot later be called a surprise.
- Any specifically negotiated exceptions relevant to your business, such as the loss of a single large customer or a known pending issue.
- If your position supports it, a specific performance provision limiting the buyer's practical ability to refuse to close and simply pay damages.
How buyers actually try to use the clause in practice
Rather than filing a lawsuit over an ambiguous MAE claim, most buyers who get cold feet after signing use the mere possibility of a MAE dispute as pressure to renegotiate price or extract concessions, betting that a seller will not want the cost and delay of a fight over whether the standard was met. Knowing this dynamic matters: how that conversation actually goes depends less on the strict legal odds of winning a case and more on how prepared you are to hold firm, with your own contemporaneous record and your own counsel ready, rather than accepting a discount just to avoid a threatened dispute.
A worked example of how the standard actually gets applied
Picture a business that loses one mid-size customer between signing and closing, representing a modest share of revenue, while the rest of the business performs in line with prior trends. A buyer might point to that loss as a reason to walk. Under the standard courts have applied, a single customer loss that does not durationally and substantially impair the company's overall earnings power over time is unlikely to meet the bar on its own, especially if losing individual customers now and then was already a normal part of the business before signing. This is exactly the kind of scenario where your disclosure schedule and your carve-out language, not the general legal standard, actually decide the outcome.
What Good Looks Like
Good practice around MAE risk means negotiating broad, specific carve-outs, disclosing known issues clearly in the disclosure schedule, and keeping a contemporaneous record of business developments during the interim period.
Building The Capability (5-Stage Skill Ladder)
How to Get Started
Disclosure: We may earn a commission if you buy through some links on this page. It doesn't change what we recommend.
Foxit eSign is a practical way to route disclosure schedule updates and any interim-period notices to the buyer for acknowledgment without delay.
A checklist tool like Process Street can help you track and timestamp notable business developments during the interim period, which is useful documentation if a MAE dispute ever comes up.
Frequently Asked Questions
How often do buyers actually succeed in invoking a MAE clause to walk away?
Historically, quite rarely. Courts have set a high bar requiring a change that is both significant in scale and durationally lasting, not a temporary dip, which means most attempts to invoke a MAE clause to escape a signed deal have not succeeded when actually litigated.
Does a bad quarter after signing let the buyer walk away?
Generally not on its own. A single disappointing quarter is usually treated as ordinary business fluctuation rather than the kind of durationally significant, substantial change that meets the typical legal standard for a material adverse effect.
What should I disclose to avoid a later MAE argument?
Disclose any known risk, pending issue, or recent negative development specifically in your disclosure schedule rather than hoping it goes unnoticed. A buyer generally cannot claim something as a surprise MAE if you disclosed it clearly before signing, which is exactly why the disclosure schedule matters as much as the MAE definition itself.
About the numbers
This guide doesn't quote a sourced benchmark. Figures in it are estimates or general guidance, so check them against your own numbers.
Related Guides
Auditing Change-of-Control Clauses in Customer Contracts
How to find and fix assignment clauses in customer contracts before a sale, so a buyer doesn't lose your biggest accounts at closing.
Asset Deal or Stock Deal: What Actually Changes for You
Compares how an asset sale and a stock sale differ on taxes, liability and what actually transfers, so you know what to ask your advisor before you sign.
Fractional Executive Agreement: Scope, Retainer and IP Clauses
The clauses a fractional executive agreement needs: scope, time, retainer, authority, IP, confidentiality, conflicts, non-solicit and termination.
How Most Favored Nation Clauses Work in Investor Side Letters
How a most favored nation clause in an investor side letter automatically extends better terms across a round, and what founders should watch for.
Operating Agreement Outline for a Multi-Member LLC With Founders
Provisions to include in a multi-member LLC operating agreement between founders: contributions, vesting, voting, transfers, buy-sell triggers and exit terms.
Transition Services Agreements: IT Cutover in a Carve-Out
How to scope, price, and set an end date for a transition services agreement so a divested unit's IT and operations cut over cleanly.