Broad-Based vs Full Ratchet Anti-Dilution, Worked Out
Anti-dilution provisions protect earlier investors when a company raises a later round at a lower price than before, commonly called a down round, by adjusting how many shares of common stock their preferred stock converts into. Broad-based weighted average and full ratchet are the two most common formulas, and they produce very different outcomes from the exact same down round.
A worked comparison shows why the choice of formula matters as much as whether anti-dilution protection exists at all.
Vendors Covered in this Article
Disclosure: We may earn a commission if you buy through some links on this page. It doesn't change what we recommend.
What full ratchet actually does
Under a full ratchet formula, the investor's original conversion price is simply reset to match the new, lower price of the down round, regardless of how many new shares were actually issued at that price. Say an earlier investor converted at a much higher price and a new round prices shares far lower: full ratchet treats the entire earlier investment as if it had been made at that new, lower price, which can dramatically increase the earlier investor's effective ownership at everyone else's expense.
What broad-based weighted average does instead
The weighted average formula adjusts the conversion price based on both the new, lower price and the relative size of the new issuance compared to the company's total existing shares. A small down round issuance moves the conversion price only a little; a very large one moves it more, but the adjustment is always proportional to the size of the dilutive event, rather than a flat reset to the new price regardless of size.
Why the practical outcomes diverge so much
Because full ratchet ignores how many shares were actually issued in the down round, it can produce a much larger adjustment, and a much larger transfer of value to the protected investor, than a weighted average formula applied to the exact same round. This is why full ratchet is considered founder-unfriendly and is far less common in typical venture financings than broad-based weighted average protection.
Where the 'broad-based' part actually matters
The weighted average calculation depends on what counts as your total outstanding share count in the formula. A 'broad-based' calculation includes a wider base, generally all common and preferred shares plus outstanding options and warrants, in that total, which produces a smaller, more founder-friendly adjustment than a 'narrow-based' version of the same weighted average formula that counts a smaller base. Confirm which version your existing agreements actually use rather than assuming all weighted average protection works the same way.
What to actually check before your next financing
Review your existing preferred stock terms for which formula applies before you negotiate a new round, since a proposed new investor may try to introduce full ratchet protection for themselves even if your earlier rounds only carry broad-based weighted average terms. Model the dilution impact of whatever is proposed against your actual cap table rather than evaluating the formula in the abstract.
Before your next financing, check these points:
- Which anti-dilution formula your existing preferred stock terms apply, before you negotiate the new round.
- Whether a new investor is asking for full ratchet protection for themselves, even if earlier rounds carry only broad-based weighted average terms.
- The dilution impact of whatever is proposed, modeled against your actual cap table rather than judged from the formula alone.
- Your agreement's carve-out list, including whether shares issued under an approved option pool are excluded from triggering an adjustment.
A worked walkthrough of the weighted average adjustment
Picture an earlier investor holding preferred stock that converts into common at a specific existing price, and a new down round that issues a relatively small number of new shares at a materially lower price. Under broad-based weighted average, the formula blends the old price and the new, lower price, weighted by how many new shares were issued relative to the company's existing total, so the adjusted conversion price moves down only modestly. Now picture the same down round issuing a much larger number of new shares instead: the same formula produces a bigger downward adjustment, because a larger issuance carries more weight in the blend, even though the new price per share did not change.
Why option pool carve-outs matter as much as the formula itself
Most agreements exclude shares issued under a board-approved employee option pool from triggering anti-dilution adjustment at all, regardless of which formula otherwise applies, which is exactly why a large new option pool created alongside a new financing sometimes gets scrutinized as an indirect way to dilute common holders without technically triggering the anti-dilution protection meant to shield preferred investors. Read the carve-out list in your existing agreements as closely as the formula itself, since a broad, generic carve-out can matter more in practice than the choice between weighted average and full ratchet.
What Good Looks Like
Good practice means knowing exactly which anti-dilution formula and which base calculation your existing agreements use, and modeling any newly proposed formula against your real cap table before agreeing to it.
Building The Capability (5-Stage Skill Ladder)
How to Get Started
Disclosure: We may earn a commission if you buy through some links on this page. It doesn't change what we recommend.
Foxit eSign helps route the amended certificate of incorporation and investor consents once an anti-dilution adjustment is formally implemented.
A platform like Rippling is a reasonable place to keep your cap table and conversion price details current so a formula comparison does not require reconstructing data from old documents.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which anti-dilution formula is more common in startup financing?
Broad-based weighted average is the more common structure in typical venture financings, since it is viewed as a fairer balance between protecting the investor and not overly penalizing the founders and other common shareholders in a down round. Full ratchet appears more often when an investor is in an unusually strong bargaining position going into the round.
Does anti-dilution protection apply to every kind of new share issuance?
No, most agreements carve out certain issuances, such as shares issued under an approved employee option pool, from triggering anti-dilution adjustment. Check your specific agreement's carve-out list, since a broadly defined set of exceptions matters as much as the formula itself.
Can founders negotiate away full ratchet protection if an investor asks for it?
Often yes, depending on how competitive the round is and how much the investor wants in. It is generally worth pushing back on full ratchet in favor of broad-based weighted average, since the practical difference for existing shareholders in an actual down round can be significant.
About the numbers
This guide doesn't quote a sourced benchmark. Figures in it are estimates or general guidance, so check them against your own numbers.
Related Guides
Working Capital Pegs: A Worked Example for Founders
Walks through a worked example of a working capital peg and true-up, so you understand what can move your payout up or down after closing.
The Governance Gaps a Pre-IPO Readiness Audit Actually Finds
What a pre-IPO governance audit checks, from SOX 404 controls to board committee independence, and how long the gaps typically take to close.
What a Board Resolution for Debt Financing Actually Needs to Say
What a lender's closing checklist expects a board resolution to cover, including security pledges, so it doesn't get sent back for revision.
Writing Board Minutes That Don't Become a Litigation Liability
How to write board minutes detailed enough to satisfy governance duties without creating language a plaintiff's lawyer can use in discovery later.
Negotiating Equity Vesting When a Founder Is Pushed Out
How single-trigger and double-trigger acceleration clauses affect a founder's unvested equity if they're removed from the company involuntarily.
The First 100 Days After an Acquisition Closes
A day-by-day framework for the first 100 days after an acquisition closes, covering systems, people, and customer retention.