Corporate Governance, Board Management & M&A ExitsPlaybook3 min readUpdated September 2026

Choosing Between AAA and JAMS Arbitration in a Contract

Buried near the back of most commercial contracts is a dispute resolution clause that gets almost no negotiating attention until the day a dispute actually happens, and by then the clause is already locked in. Choosing arbitration over litigation, and choosing which provider administers it, changes cost, timeline, and how much control either side has over the outcome.

The American Arbitration Association and JAMS are the two providers most commercial contracts name, and they're not interchangeable. Each has its own rules, fee structure, and roster of arbitrators, and the differences matter most in exactly the disputes you're trying to plan for now.

Vendors Covered in this Article

Disclosure: We may earn a commission if you buy through some links on this page. It doesn't change what we recommend.

What Arbitration Trades Away Compared to Litigation

Arbitration is generally faster and more private than litigation, and the parties get to pick a decision-maker with relevant subject-matter experience rather than whichever judge is assigned. In exchange, arbitration awards are extremely difficult to appeal, discovery is typically more limited than in court, and there's no jury.

For a contract involving a counterparty you expect to have an ongoing relationship with, that speed and privacy often outweighs the loss of appeal rights. For a dispute where you'd want a public record, broad discovery, or a jury's judgment on a fact-heavy question, litigation can be the better default even though it's slower.

How AAA and JAMS Actually Differ in Practice

AAA administers a very high volume of commercial cases and offers tiered procedures, including an expedited track for smaller disputes, with published fee schedules based on the amount in controversy. JAMS generally handles a smaller volume, leans toward more experienced, often retired-judge arbitrators, and tends to be positioned for higher-value or more complex commercial disputes, with fee structures that reflect that positioning.

Neither provider is categorically faster or cheaper; it depends heavily on the specific case type, the arbitrator selected, and which procedural track applies. What matters most in drafting is naming the provider explicitly and specifying which set of rules, commercial, expedited, or another named track, applies, rather than leaving the clause to reference the provider generically.

Drafting the Clause So It Actually Works When You Need It

A workable arbitration clause names the administering provider, the applicable rules, the seat, the legal location governing the arbitration, which can differ from where hearings actually happen, the number of arbitrators, and the language of the proceeding. Missing any of these leaves room for a preliminary fight over procedure before the actual dispute even gets addressed.

Also specify whether the clause covers all disputes arising from the contract or only certain categories, and whether either side retains the right to seek injunctive relief in court for specific situations, like protecting confidential information, that don't fit well into an arbitration timeline.

When Litigation Is Still the Better Default

Arbitration isn't automatically the safer choice. If you expect to need a fast preliminary injunction, if the contract involves a counterparty in a jurisdiction where arbitration awards are hard to enforce, or if you want the deterrent effect of a public court record for a category of dispute, like intellectual property theft, where reputation matters, a litigation clause with a chosen venue and governing law can serve you better.

Some contracts use a hybrid approach: arbitration for payment and performance disputes, carved out with an explicit right to seek injunctive relief in court for confidentiality or intellectual property breaches. That split lets each side use the mechanism suited to the type of dispute most likely to actually arise under that specific contract.

Common Drafting Mistakes That Surface Only During a Real Dispute

A short list of drafting problems account for most of the fights that happen before the actual dispute gets heard:

  • Naming a provider without specifying which set of rules applies, leaving room to argue over procedure.
  • No stated seat for the arbitration, creating uncertainty over which jurisdiction's arbitration law governs.
  • No carve-out for injunctive relief, forcing an urgent confidentiality dispute through a multi-month arbitration timeline.
  • Silence on whether the arbitrator can award attorneys' fees, which varies significantly depending on the provider's default rules and the governing state law.
Executive Capability Standard

What Good Looks Like

A workable dispute resolution clause names the specific administering provider and rules track, states an explicit seat and arbitrator count, and carves out injunctive relief for disputes, like confidentiality breaches, that don't fit an arbitration timeline.

Building The Capability (5-Stage Skill Ladder)

1. Learn:Read your current template contract's dispute resolution clause and note whether it names a specific provider, rules track, and seat, or just gestures at arbitration generally.
2. Do Manually:Draft the seat, rules track, and injunctive relief carve-out yourself for your standard contract template, then have counsel review the language before it goes into use.
3. Delegate:Have outside counsel review and finalize the arbitration clause for any contract above a size where a dispute would meaningfully affect the business.
4. Automate:Use contract templates with the dispute resolution clause pre-populated correctly so it isn't redrafted, and potentially weakened, contract by contract.
5. Buy:Bring in counsel experienced in commercial arbitration specifically when negotiating a high-value contract or one with a cross-border counterparty.

How to Get Started

Disclosure: We may earn a commission if you buy through some links on this page. It doesn't change what we recommend.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is an arbitration clause always enforceable if one side later doesn't want to arbitrate?

Generally yes, as long as the clause is properly drafted and the underlying agreement is valid. Courts strongly favor enforcing arbitration clauses under federal and most state law, so a party trying to avoid arbitration after signing usually has a difficult argument to make, absent a specific defect in how the clause was formed.

Can a company choose AAA for some contracts and JAMS for others?

Yes, and many companies do, often based on the counterparty's preference or the deal size. There's no requirement to standardize on one provider across every contract, though keeping a consistent internal default for your own template contracts does simplify things when a dispute eventually arises.

Does arbitration cost more or less than litigation overall?

It depends on the dispute. Arbitration filing and arbitrator fees can be higher upfront than court filing fees, but the more limited discovery and faster timeline often make the total cost lower for a straightforward contract dispute. Complex, multi-year litigation is usually the more expensive path by the time it resolves.

Should every commercial contract include the same arbitration language?

A standard template clause is a reasonable starting point, but revisit it for high-value or cross-border contracts. Enforcement, seat selection, and language provisions matter more as the stakes and cross-border complexity increase.

About the numbers

This guide doesn't quote a sourced benchmark. Figures in it are estimates or general guidance, so check them against your own numbers.

Related Guides