Why Non-Solicitation Clauses Hold Up More Than Non-Competes
Non-compete clauses have gotten harder to enforce almost everywhere, and a handful of states void them for employees outright, with a growing list of others restricting them further. Non-solicitation and non-disparagement clauses live in a different, generally sturdier legal category, but sturdier isn't the same as automatically enforceable.
Understanding why courts treat these clauses differently, and drafting them with that reasoning in mind, is what actually determines whether they hold up if a departing employee or executive tests them.
Why Courts Treat Non-Solicitation Differently From Non-Competes
A non-compete restrains someone from working in a field, or for a competitor, at all, which courts have increasingly treated as an unreasonable restraint on a person's ability to earn a living. A non-solicitation clause only restrains someone from actively contacting the company's specific customers or employees to lure them away; it doesn't stop that person from working anywhere they choose.
That narrower restraint is exactly why courts are more willing to uphold non-solicitation clauses even in states that have clamped down hard on non-competes. The clause is protecting a specific relationship the company built, not blocking a person's livelihood generally.
What makes a non-solicitation clause enforceable?
Three things tend to determine whether a court upholds one: a reasonable duration, commonly framed as one to two years rather than an open-ended restriction; a reasonable scope, limited to customers or colleagues the departing person actually had contact with or confidential knowledge about, not the company's entire customer base regardless of that person's role; and genuine consideration, something of value exchanged for agreeing to the restriction.
When the clause is signed at the start of employment, the job offer itself is usually sufficient consideration. When it's added to an existing employee's terms later, several states require something additional, a raise or a promotion, for example, before the new restriction is enforceable at all.
Non-Disparagement Clauses: A Different Legal Animal With Its Own Limits
A non-disparagement clause restrains negative public statements about the company, and it's generally enforceable on its own terms. But it runs into real limits where it would chill an employee's protected right to discuss wages or working conditions, or to report unlawful conduct to a government agency.
A growing number of states have also restricted using non-disparagement language in the settlement of harassment or discrimination claims specifically, so a clause that reads fine in an ordinary departure agreement can be unenforceable, or even unlawful, in that narrower context.
How do you draft clauses that survive a later challenge?
Tie the restricted customer or employee list to people the departing person actually worked with or knew confidentially, rather than a blanket company-wide list that sweeps in relationships they never touched. State a specific, defensible duration rather than leaving it open-ended, and carve out ordinary general advertising or an employee's own unprompted decision to apply elsewhere, since a clause broad enough to block that kind of independent action invites a court to strike the whole provision.
For non-disparagement language specifically, build in an explicit exception for legally protected communications, reports to a government agency, participation in an investigation, discussion of wages, rather than leaving a court to read that exception in on its own.
It also helps to separate the two clauses in the document rather than folding them into one broad paragraph. A court reviewing a challenge to the non-disparagement language shouldn't have to untangle it from the non-solicitation terms just to evaluate each one on its own footing.
Common Mistakes That Weaken an Otherwise Reasonable Clause
The same handful of drafting choices show up in most of the clauses that get struck down or narrowed by a court:
- Copying broad non-compete language into a non-solicitation clause without narrowing its scope to actual relationships.
- Applying the same duration to every role regardless of seniority or access to sensitive customer relationships.
- Drafting non-disparagement language broad enough to sweep in protected complaints or wage discussions.
- Adding the clause to an existing employee's terms without offering separate consideration for the new restriction.
What Good Looks Like
An enforceable clause restricts contact only with customers or employees the departing person actually worked with or knew confidentially, states a specific and defensible duration, and never extends into territory, like blocking a protected complaint, that courts treat as against public policy.
Building The Capability (5-Stage Skill Ladder)
How to Get Started
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a non-solicitation clause enforceable in a state that bans non-competes?
Often yes, since most states that restrict non-competes still treat non-solicitation clauses as a narrower, more defensible restraint. It isn't universal, though, and a handful of states limit or restrict even non-solicitation clauses in specific circumstances, so it's worth checking the current law in the state that governs the agreement.
Can a non-disparagement clause stop a former employee from filing a complaint with a government agency?
No. Clauses that would prevent someone from filing a charge with an agency like the EEOC or the NLRB, or from participating in an investigation, are generally unenforceable regardless of how they're worded, since that right exists independent of what any private agreement says.
Does a non-solicitation clause need to name specific customers to be enforceable?
No, a non-solicitation clause doesn't need to name specific customers, but it should cover only the customers or employees the departing person actually dealt with or knew confidentially. Scoping it to the company's entire customer base, regardless of that person's role and access, makes it much easier to challenge and narrow in court.
Do these clauses need separate payment or consideration to be valid?
If included at the start of employment, the job offer itself is generally sufficient consideration. If added to an existing employee's terms later, several states require something additional, extra compensation or a promotion, for example, to make the new restriction enforceable, so timing affects what's required.
About the numbers
This guide doesn't quote a sourced benchmark. Figures in it are estimates or general guidance, so check them against your own numbers.
Related Guides
A 30-Minute Audit for Executive Severance Agreements
A short audit founders can run on their own executive severance agreements to catch non-compete enforceability gaps before they matter.
Liquidation Preference Stacks: A Worked Payout Example
A worked example showing how a participating preference changes the payout waterfall in an exit compared to a standard non-participating structure.
How Most Favored Nation Clauses Work in Investor Side Letters
How a most favored nation clause in an investor side letter automatically extends better terms across a round, and what founders should watch for.
Auditing Change-of-Control Clauses in Customer Contracts
How to find and fix assignment clauses in customer contracts before a sale, so a buyer doesn't lose your biggest accounts at closing.
MAE Clauses: When a Buyer Can Actually Walk Away
Explains how a material adverse effect clause works from both sides, what usually gets carved out, and why buyers rarely win a case built on one.
Choosing Between AAA and JAMS Arbitration in a Contract
How AAA and JAMS arbitration differ in cost, timeline, and process, and when litigation is still the better choice for a commercial contract.